Knowledge Center

HIE and Data Security Breech Potential

John Concannon's picture

One chief concern for us is the liability issues for health care providers accessing to upload or view patient confidential information through an Internet source such as CurrentCare.  It appears there is currently no good mechanism in place to indemnify the individual health care provider should a system-wide data breach occur, such as happened in Virginia where state-held patient health information was hacked and held for ransom (see: http://voices.washingtonpost.com/securityfix/2009/05/hackers_break_into_virginia_he.html ).  Attorney General oversight and Federal privacy laws are powerless to prevent or punish dedicated hackers residing in Russia or China.  National Public Radio broadcast a segment last month reporting that even the National Security Agency cannot guarantee that any part of the national computer infrastructure is safe from such attacks, including that of our nation’s military ( http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=127411091

The RI Assembly must immediately legislate indemnification for providers to prevent severe economic losses due to lawsuits and Red Flag compliance issues (whether or not Red Flag compliance for medical practices actually becomes mandated by law).  Currently, it is impossible for providers to even buy insurance coverage to cover any such losses.  Any ‘Trust Agreement’ that we must sign should stipulate such indemnity to providers when electronic access is used in good faith. 

One of the driving concerns that led our practice to dump the Lifespan.asp hosting of our eClinicalWorks application and spend over $13,000 to bring in our own servers was this very vulnerability.  While individual servers connected to the Internet are likewise vulnerable, simple mathematics dictate that the large size of hospital system or governmental-run servers makes for much more inviting targets for such hacks.

Of course we utilize common methods to protect our systems such as robust firewalls and regularly updated antivirus software. We also isolate some of our connectivity to the Internet by utilizing separate computers not hosting our eHR system.

So the question is, what are other practices doing to confront these potential problems? Please avoid bureaucratic responses that do not address the concrete things we must do.

John Concannon's picture

More disturbing news:  Health IT Breaches are more common than others would have you believe.  See http://www.ihealthbeat.org/articles/2010/9/8/breaches-of-health-care-dat...

John Concannon's picture

UNHAPPY CAMPER (Vol 1, Issue 1)

According to today's iHealthBeat these patient health data security breaches will cost, on average $200 PER PATIENT RECORD to handle.  If we are to embrace EMR we need liability protection.  See: http://www.ihealthbeat.org/articles/2010/8/13/security-breaches-may-caus...

And yet more legislative-doctor-unfriendly proposals at http://www.ihealthbeat.org/articles/2010/8/17/new-senate-legislation-tac...

John Concannon's picture

Yet more on why we need liability protection for data breaches in the following link ironically posted today: http://www.ihealthbeat.org/articles/2010/7/30/hhs-pulls-from-review-prop... There are even more hair-raising pieces from iHealthBeat in the "related articles links" on the right column.

Consider the above posting to have been 'Unhappy Camper' Vol 1, Issue 1